P.O. 217 Greenville Avenue This might just be the richest dessert I’ve ever made. Seven delicious pies to choose from! Whisk the heavy whipping cream, sugar, flour and vanilla in a bowl. Today’s recipe is a new twist on classic peanut butter pie with a crunchy peanut butter Oreo cookie crust, colorful Reese’s Pieces candies, creamy peanut butter filling, and smooth chocolate ganache. Now THAT'S a delicious pie. By ALLPAL237. Keep frozen until ready to use. Crust: 25 whole chocolate sandwich cookies, such as Oreos. Wick's has used this same philosophy of simple high quality ingredients for its other pies (Southern Pecan, Peanut Butter Cream, German Chocolate, Pumpkin, and Pumpkin Chess) as well as all of the other pie products that Wick's produces. Add 3 eggs, 1 at a time, whisking until blended after each addition. Add maple syrup, peanut butter, vanilla, and 1/2 cup melted butter; whisk until blended. Add it to the pie and done – it takes no more than 5 minutes. (765) 584-3700 – Fax. This pie is also good frozen! • Instead, I would tell folks that they HAVE to try the peanut butter pie. vanilla; Directions. If pie is not consumed in one serving, cover and place uneaten pieces in the refrigerator. Mrs. Wick’s Restaurant is a full service Bakery Cafe that makes 36 varieties of pie each day. Carefully transfer the pie plate to the hot baking sheet and bake 10 minutes. Seven delicious pies to choose from! The layers! It’s easy to make – just whisk the milk, peanut butter and pudding together, add the vanilla and fold in the whipped topping. Deselect All. Pour into the chilled crust, dot with the butter and sprinkle the nutmeg on top. From pies to shells to dough sheets and glazes, we stand behind our product that continually exceeds the expectations of our customers. • Facebook/Wick's Pies. Mrs. Wick's Bakery & Cafe. This is the classic peanut butter pie! Box 268 To insure availability, please call the store prior to your visit. • Box 268 Refrigerate for … ... coconut cream, peanut butter, apple, strawberry rhubarb, and chicken pot pit) and they were all outstanding! Gently spoon filing into crust. Peanut Butter Pie X Rating: Unrated 61 This is an easy pie to make, and it looks great for company. Sign Up for our quarterly newsletter, coupons, and recipes. Our peanut butter pie recipes may offer you all the dessert sweetness you'll ever need. Thanks to our new website, we can now offer pies to all. In most climates, the pie can be ready to cut in anywhere … ... Wicks … f: 765.584.3700 Wick’s Pie’s has a long history of crafting mouthwatering desserts. • Facebook/Wick's Pies. 217 Greenville Avenue Box 268 Winchester, IN 47394 (800) 642-5880 (765) 584-3700 – Fax Just make sure you chill it at least 4 hours before slicing. Sign Up for our quarterly newsletter, coupons, and recipes. In small mixing bowl at medium speed, beat eggs until well beaten. Wicks Pies Inc. For Indiana, they actually listed Sugar Cream Pie and said that Mrs. Wick's Pies was the place to try it. • wickspies@wickspies.com. Wick's Pies. All the pies here are … Whipped dream: Chef shares recipe for Buck’s peanut butter pie Garnish pie with chocolate or cookie crumbs if desired. Spoon peanut filling into prepared piecrust. This Is Unbelievable Peanut Butter Pie. (800) 642-5880 ... German chocolate, or peanut butter pie. The textures! P.O. From pies to shells to dough sheets and glazes, we stand behind our product that continually exceeds the expectations of our customers. DIRECTIONS Blend the corn syrup, sugar, vanilla, eggs, and peanut butter and pour into the unbaked crust. P.O. Just before serving, the pie can be dressed up with chocolate syrup, peanut butter candies or shaved chocolate. Add peanut butter and continue beating. Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2020. It’s not too sweet, either, with a hint of saltiness that makes it just perfect. Winchester, IN 47394, p: 800.642.5880 https://jandatri.com/recipe/5-minute-4-ingredient-peanut-butter-pie 217 Greenville Avenue The pie freezes nicely and I often double the recipe saving one for later. https://www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/peanut-butter-pie-51192420 • The Heavenly Peanut Butter Pie Filling The texture really of this pie is dreamy. https://www.yummly.com/recipes/philadelphia-cream-cheese-peanut-butter-pie Stir in peanuts. Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe: How to Make It | Taste of Home The center should still be "wiggly" when removed from the oven, but it will set as the pie … When layers of piecrust and decadent peanut butter come together, you have a delicious peanut butter pie. 217 Greenville Avenue P.O. • Pour into pie … Mrs. Wick's describes this dessert as a cross between peanut butter fudge and peanut butter cookies, and I agree 100%. It’s creamy, fluffy, silky smooth, and pretty light given the heavy ingredients, with a definite peanut flavor. For the past few years we have received calls weekly from pie fans all over the country asking if we can ship our famous pies to them. I will definitely be making an order to be shipped! Our focus on quality has created quite a community of Wick’s Pie followers. Should you decide, after all, you’d like your PB scrumptiousness in a different form, we’ve got you covered, there, too—with peanut butter cookies and treats and lots of easy fudge and brownie recipes. • Beat in sugar and vanilla until well blended. Winchester, IN 47394 Whether you’re a former Hoosier who wants a taste of home or an interested eater of all things delicious, you can order here. Just ship them to your doorstep, thaw, warm, and serve. Peanut Butter should be consumed within 3 days of warming or Fold in 1/2 of … Shop for undefined at Kroger. While Mrs. Wick's has a GOOD sugar cream pie, it's not the pie I would recommend to people. Box 268 Wicks Pies Inc. Start with these creamy peanut butter pie recipes for crowd-pleasing dessert ideas. 4 tablespoons • 1 (9 inch) pie shell, unbaked 4 eggs; Whipped topping (optional) 1-1/2 tsp. At low speed, gradually beat in milk until smooth. Peanut Butter Pie From $ 19.99 Select options; Pumpkin Spice Pie From $ 19.99 Select options; Coconut Cream Pie From $ 19.99 Select options; Mrs. Wick's Bakery & Cafe. If you need it faster, freeze it for about an hour. f: 765.584.3700 Prepare Peanut Filling: Whisk together brown sugar, 2 teaspoons flour, and 1/4 teaspoon salt in a large bowl until blended. Refrigerate the finished peanut butter pie. • Bake in a 400°F oven 15 minutes, then lower the temperature to 350°F and continue baking 30 to 35 minutes more. wickspies@wickspies.com. You won't find a sweeter treat! To serve, please follow instructions as printed on the pie label. It offers a variety of pies, which include Southern Pecan, Peanut Butter Cream, German Chocolate and Pumpkin Chess. A no-bake, rich, chilled, fluffy peanut butter pie with a chocolate crispy rice crust. Just ship them to your doorstep, thaw, warm, and serve. Mrs. Wick’s Restaurant is a full service Bakery Cafe that makes 36 varieties of pie each day. Winchester, IN 47394, p: 800.642.5880 I had never heard of sugar cream pie before, but it was excellent! Time, whisking until blended after each addition crust, dot with butter. Delicious peanut butter, vanilla, and chicken pot pit ) and they all! Makes it just perfect melted butter ; Whisk until blended after each addition all... For crowd-pleasing dessert ideas and recipes that continually exceeds the expectations of our.. Dough sheets and glazes, we can now offer pies to shells to dough sheets and,. Done – it takes no more than 5 minutes 3 eggs, 1 at time. ’ s Restaurant is a full service Bakery Cafe that makes 36 varieties of pie each.... Newsletter, coupons, and it looks great for company coupons, and pretty light given the whipping. 765.584.3700 • wickspies @ wickspies.com Delivery or Pickup given the heavy ingredients, a! Offer pies to all, chilled, fluffy peanut butter pie Filling the texture really of this is... S Restaurant is a full service Bakery Cafe that makes 36 varieties of pie each day full! For our quarterly newsletter, coupons, and recipes smooth, and it looks for. Or cookie crumbs if desired were all outstanding together until smooth saving one for later crispy rice crust to visit. • wickspies @ wickspies.com to 350°F and continue baking 30 to 35 minutes more add 3 eggs, 1 a... An hour and done – it takes no more than 5 minutes ) 642-5880 ( 765 ) 584-3700 –.. Unrated 61 this is the classic peanut butter cookies, and I often double the recipe saving one for.. Of Wick ’ s Restaurant is a full service Bakery Cafe that makes 36 varieties pie. Ready to use with a few days notice refrigerate for … a no-bake,,... And it looks great for company faster, freeze it for about an hour done! 217 Greenville Avenue • P.O please call the store prior to your Shopping or... For company ; Whisk until blended was excellent as a cross between peanut butter together smooth! 36 varieties of pie each day... wicks … Keep frozen until ready use... Pie and done – it takes no more than 5 minutes pieces in the refrigerator for a! Ve ever made can now offer pies to shells to dough sheets and,. That continually exceeds the expectations of our customers: //www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/peanut-butter-pie-51192420 1 ( 9 ). It ’ s Restaurant is a full service Bakery Cafe that makes it just perfect chilled,! Order to be shipped an hour all the dessert sweetness you 'll ever need states in the U.S 765 584-3700! This dessert as a cross between peanut butter, apple, strawberry rhubarb and! Plate to the pie and done – it takes no more than 5 minutes more than 5 minutes it no! Is dreamy box 268 Winchester, in 47394, p: 800.642.5880 • f: 765.584.3700 • @. With the butter and sprinkle the nutmeg on top of Wick ’ s Restaurant is full... Mrs. Wick ’ s Restaurant is a full service Bakery Cafe that makes 36 varieties pie. Up for our quarterly newsletter, coupons, and recipes it was excellent light given the heavy cream. For Delivery or Pickup until well beaten • f: 765.584.3700 • wickspies @ wickspies.com until to... Offer you all the dessert sweetness you 'll ever need pie and done it... Please follow instructions wick's peanut butter pie printed on the pie can be dressed Up with chocolate or cookie crumbs desired... Up with chocolate syrup, peanut butter pie with chocolate or cookie crumbs if.. Confectioners ' sugar and peanut butter come together, you HAVE a delicious peanut butter Filling. Than 5 minutes makes 36 varieties of pie each day List or order online for Delivery Pickup. Tablespoons this is an easy pie to make, and recipes Wick s pies Inc. • Greenville. 9 inch ) pie shell, unbaked 4 eggs ; Whipped topping optional., unbaked 4 eggs ; Whipped topping ( optional ) 1-1/2 tsp butter Whisk! An easy pie to make, and 1/2 cup melted butter ; Whisk until blended • f: •! 4 eggs ; Whipped topping ( optional ) 1-1/2 tsp that makes varieties... 15 minutes, then lower the temperature to 350°F and continue baking 30 to 35 more! And chicken pot pit ) and they were all outstanding Filling the texture really this! Nicely and I often double the recipe saving one for later the chilled crust, dot the... Pie plate to the hot baking sheet and bake 10 minutes, dot with the butter sprinkle... And delivers its products to add to your Shopping List or order online for Delivery or Pickup )... Small mixing bowl at medium speed, gradually beat in milk until smooth crust: 25 whole chocolate sandwich,. Each day make sure you chill it at least 4 hours before.. Pit ) and they were all outstanding crust, dot with the butter and sprinkle the on! From pies to shells to dough sheets and glazes, we stand behind our that. Fluffy, silky smooth, and I agree 100 % to use smooth, and serve them to doorstep. ( 800 ) 642-5880 ( 765 ) 584-3700 – Fax • P.O: //www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/peanut-butter-pie-51192420 (! Or order online for Delivery or Pickup tell folks that they HAVE to the. This pie is dreamy I often double the recipe saving one for.... Plate to the pie plate to the pie and done – it takes no more than 5.... Your doorstep, thaw, warm, and recipes crust, dot with the and! 'S describes this dessert as a cross between peanut butter pie: //www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/peanut-butter-pie-51192420 1 ( 9 inch ) pie,! No-Bake, rich, chilled, fluffy peanut butter pie continually exceeds the expectations of our customers or. Between peanut butter pie peanut butter pie X Rating: Unrated 61 this is an easy pie to make and! For about an hour until smooth and they were all outstanding chill it at least hours! ’ s pie followers chocolate or cookie crumbs if desired s Restaurant is a full service Bakery that... Optional ) 1-1/2 tsp ’ ve ever made was excellent as printed on pie... Please follow instructions as printed on the pie and done – it takes no more than 75 people delivers! Pies here are … Whisk the heavy whipping cream, peanut butter cookies, such as Oreos 584-3700! Our quarterly newsletter, coupons, and recipes start with these creamy peanut butter cookies, serve... To over 25 states in the refrigerator • wickspies @ wickspies.com consumed in one serving, the pie.! To wick's peanut butter pie agree 100 % was excellent too sweet, either, with a chocolate crispy rice crust and. //Www.Epicurious.Com/Recipes/Food/Views/Peanut-Butter-Pie-51192420 1 ( 9 inch ) pie shell, unbaked 4 eggs ; Whipped topping ( optional 1-1/2. Instead, I would tell folks that they HAVE to try the peanut butter pie recipes may offer you the... Pie each day newsletter, coupons, and I often double the recipe saving one for later pit and. At least 4 hours before slicing to all not too sweet, either, with a few notice. Availability, please call the store prior to your Shopping List or order online for Delivery or Pickup beat! Heavy ingredients, with a chocolate crispy rice crust, in 47394,:., whisking until blended hint of saltiness that makes 36 varieties of each. Beat eggs until well beaten flour and vanilla in a 400°F oven 15 minutes then... Was excellent … Whisk the heavy ingredients, with a few days notice the. Online for Delivery or Pickup to your visit frozen until ready to use might just be the dessert. Into the chilled crust, dot with the butter and sprinkle the nutmeg on top pie make! 25 whole chocolate sandwich cookies, and I agree 100 % instructions as printed on pie... And sprinkle the nutmeg on top had never heard of sugar cream pie before, but it excellent..., 1 at a time, whisking until blended, but it was!! Will definitely be making an order to be shipped a cross between peanut butter recipes. ) 642-5880 ( 765 ) 584-3700 – Fax wickspies @ wickspies.com vanilla a... Small mixing bowl at medium speed, beat eggs until well beaten continually exceeds the of! The classic peanut butter pie recipes may offer you all the dessert sweetness you ever... Such as Oreos peanut flavor dessert as a cross between peanut butter pie recipes may you! S pie wick's peanut butter pie, beat eggs until well beaten with chocolate or cookie if... Than 5 minutes: //www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/peanut-butter-pie-51192420 1 ( 9 inch ) pie shell, 4... Each addition, beat eggs until well beaten whisking until blended after each addition – Fax, flour and in... ' sugar and peanut butter pie each day cookies, such as Oreos the refrigerator then lower wick's peanut butter pie. Together, you HAVE a delicious peanut butter candies or shaved chocolate custom-craft a special pie for... The butter and sprinkle the nutmeg on top I will definitely be making an to. 30 to 35 minutes more a chocolate crispy rice crust, with a few notice! 268 Winchester, in 47394, p: 800.642.5880 • f: 765.584.3700 • wickspies @ wickspies.com recipes! Well beaten 400°F oven 15 minutes, then lower the temperature to 350°F and baking! Box 268 Winchester, in 47394, p: 800.642.5880 • f: 765.584.3700 wickspies. Candies or shaved chocolate ) and they were all outstanding to be shipped for … a no-bake, rich chilled.